Trade-offs Are Where Leadership Becomes Real
Every real trade-off comes with a critic.
A decision nobody can criticize usually means nothing was given up.
In 2009, North Carolina was in serious financial trouble, like most states in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. I was the state’s Secretary of Revenue. The legislature’s finance committee asked me to come over for a meeting. They had one question. They put it in earthier terms, but what they meant was this: how much can you raise without angering the taxpayers?
That ruled out the easy answers. No new taxes. No new fees. Whatever we did had to bring in real money, quickly, without landing on the people who were already paying.
I went back to the department and filled a conference room for a full day: my direct reports, their direct reports, and our subject-matter experts, some of whom were leaders themselves. Many were surprised to be included. Before long the walls were covered. What about this? What about that? Ideas came from everyone, fast and furious. Some were good. Some were not.
The idea that won the day came from someone on the Corporate Tax team. I wish I could tell you who. That’s what that room was like.
About 300 corporate entities owed the state significant amounts. When I saw the aging, I couldn’t believe it: balances 5, 8, 10, even 12 years old. One company’s balance alone would eventually come in as a nine-figure check. The normal collection process had been working on those accounts for years. Nothing suggested more of the same would move them now.
The idea came from the team. The call was mine, and the pressure at the time was intense. In a fiscal crisis, the Revenue guy is usually not everybody’s best friend.
So we changed the offer. I sent a letter to the CFO of each company. If they came in, met with our people, and worked out a resolution consistent with the law, they would pay what they owed plus interest, and I would waive the penalty. The penalty ran about 10 percent, and the statute gave me the authority to waive it.
We sent more than 300 letters with no idea how they would land. We mailed them and waited. Then the responses started coming in, and we had work to do. 235 companies replied. My team carried that load, and they were among the hardest-working people I’ve ever had the pleasure to work with. In six months, the program brought in $525 million.
It also cost something. By our rough estimate, the penalties we waived came to more than $50 million. Most people applauded the result. The six o’clock news did not. Critics said I had left money on the table at the moment the state could least afford it.
They weren’t wrong about the arithmetic. That’s what made it a trade-off.
The choice was never between $525 million and $575 million. It was between $525 million and what those balances had produced in 12 years.
Without an offer, no company had a reason to walk through the door. The penalty that was supposed to compel payment had become one more reason to stay away. The full amount existed on paper. What we collected existed in the state’s accounts.
Not every problem needs the same lever. When the default tool has been applied for years and the problem is still there, applying it harder isn’t a strategy. It’s a habit. The more useful question is what would make the other party want to move.
One CFO told me afterward that the department’s willingness to have a reasonable conversation, instead of an adversarial one, was what brought his company to the table. He was one person. But more than 200 companies made the same decision. The ones that didn’t respond carried on as before, and their penalties kept accruing. The offer was generous. It wasn’t soft.
I chose not to respond to the critics. I let the results do the talking.
That’s the part leaders tend to underestimate. A real trade-off means giving up something of value, and someone will always point to what you gave up. A leader who needs every choice to be beyond criticism will keep defaulting to the options that ask nothing of them. That is how problems sit for 12 years.
When I work with a leader facing a hard call, I’m less interested in the answer they’re leaning toward than in how they got there. These are the questions I ask:
- Have you looked at the problem from every perspective that matters?
- Have you exercised all your options, or only the ones you’ve always used?
- Have you considered the unintended consequences?
- Have you put your own preconceived biases on the table?
- What are you willing to give up?
- Who is closest to the problem and hasn’t been asked for an idea?
Most hard calls go wrong on one of those questions long before the decision itself.
Leadership becomes real at the point where you decide what you’re willing to lose.
What are you protecting right now that’s keeping you from the result you need?